The mid-1990s were a period of transformation for Ballynahinch RFC. Having secured senior status, the club quickly climbed the All-Ireland League (AIL) ladder. Promotion in 1996–97 brought them to Division 3, and a year later they advanced again to Division 2. The late 1990s and early 2000s were marked by fluctuation — a relegation in 1998–99 sent them back to Division 3, but they returned to Division 2 in 2000–01.

Although mid-table stability followed, relegation struck again in 2005–06. Yet, characteristically, Ballynahinch bounced back immediately in 2006–07 to re-establish themselves in Division 2. These years reflected the club’s determination and resilience, setting the stage for something remarkable.

The Quadruple Season (2008–09)

The 2008–09 campaign remains the most iconic in Ballynahinch’s history. The team achieved an unprecedented “quadruple” of trophies:
AIB All-Ireland Cup, becoming the first Division 2 side to win the national knockout competition.
All-Ireland League Division 2 title, sealing promotion to Division 1 after defeating UCC in the play-off final.
Ulster Senior Cup, defeating Ballymena 19–0 in the final.
Ulster Senior League, topping the table.
This extraordinary year transformed Ballynahinch’s standing in Irish rugby and demonstrated the club’s ability to challenge the traditional giants.

Establishment, Setbacks, and Revival (2010–2019)

The 2010s tested Ballynahinch’s staying power at the highest levels. Competing in Division 1A was always a challenge for a community club from County Down, but they consistently produced competitive sides and nurtured talented Ulster-qualified players.

At provincial level, Ballynahinch became dominant. They captured the Ulster Senior Cup three years running (2014–15, 2015–16, 2016–17), cementing their status as Ulster’s leading senior club outside of the professional provincial setup.

Relegation from Division 1A in 2016 was a setback, but the club regrouped. Their revival culminated in 2018–19, when Ballynahinch were crowned Division 1B champions, earning a well-deserved return to the top flight. This achievement underlined the strength of their squad, coaching, and community support.

Survival and Success in the 2020s

The 2020s have been about consolidation. Competing in AIL Division 1A, Ballynahinch have faced relegation battles but have shown grit when it mattered most. A dramatic survival in 2021–22, defeating UCC in a two-legged relegation play-off, highlighted their resilience. Since then the club has consolidated it's position in the League coming 5th for the past 3 seasons (2022/23, 2023/24, 2024/25).

Meanwhile, Ulster silverware kept flowing. They lifted the Ulster Senior League in 2018–19, 2021–22, 2022–23, and 2023–24, proving their consistent provincial strength. In knockout competitions, they claimed the Ulster Senior Cup in 2022–23, overcoming Queen’s University, and again in 2024–25 with a resounding 50–3 victory over Dungannon.

And the club retains strength in depth winning multiple other cup competitions including in 2023/24 the Forster Cup & Ravenhill Cup and in 2024/25 the Towns Cup & McCambley Cup.

These triumphs showed that even when fighting for survival nationally, Ballynahinch remained the benchmark for success in Ulster club rugby.

1XV Honours Recap (1996–2025)

All-Ireland League Promotions:
1996–97 (to Division 3)
1997–98 (to Division 2)
2008–09 (to Division 1)
2018–19 (to Division 1A as 1B champions)

All-Ireland Cup:
2008–09

Ulster Senior Cup:
2008–09, 2014–15, 2015–16, 2016–17, 2022–23, 2024–25

Ulster Senior League:
2008–09, 2012–13, 2013–14, 2014–15, 2018–19, 2021–22, 2022–23, 2023–24